Back to Blog
Why the Yankees and Rays Played Three Games in 24 Hours
September 25, 2026
The New York Yankees and Tampa Bay Rays played three full games between September 22nd and September 23rd. The schedule packed a doubleheader (two games on the same day) on September 22nd, then another game the next day. This created an unusual situation where three complete games happened in less than 24 hours.
This post explains why this happened, what it means for betting markets and how to spot value when teams play on compressed schedules.
What Is a Doubleheader?
A doubleheader is when two games between the same teams are played on the same day. Major League Baseball schedules doubleheaders for two reasons: makeup games after rain delays or postponements and traditional scheduled doubleheaders (rare in today’s baseball).
Most doubleheaders now are seven innings per game instead of the standard nine innings. This rule started during the COVID-shortened 2020 season and MLB kept it for makeup doubleheaders through 2023. In 2024, makeup doubleheaders returned to nine innings per game.
The time between games in a doubleheader is usually about 30 minutes. Teams use the same roster for both games but manage pitchers and position players differently because of fatigue.
Why Three Games in 24 Hours Happened?
The Yankees and Rays had a makeup game to play from an earlier rainout. MLB scheduled it as part of a doubleheader on September 22nd. The league already had a regularly scheduled game between these teams on September 23rd.
This created a situation where the teams played twice on the 22nd, then once more the following day. The timing meant three complete games within a span of roughly 24 hours.
MLB scheduling rules require makeup games to fit into the existing calendar. Late-season schedules have little flexibility because teams need equal numbers of home and away games. When a game gets rained out, the league looks for the next available off day or slots it into an existing series as a doubleheader.
How Compressed Schedules Affect Teams?
Playing three games in 24 hours creates roster management challenges. Starting pitchers cannot pitch on short rest, so teams rely heavily on their bullpen (relief pitchers who pitch shorter stretches).
Position players (non-pitchers) face fatigue from limited recovery time between games. Managers often rest regular starters in one game of a doubleheader and use backup players. This changes the quality of both offense and defense.
Teams with deeper rosters (more quality backup players) handle these situations better than teams with thin benches. The bullpen depth matters most because relief pitchers throw in multiple games across the stretch.
Betting Market Adjustments for Compressed Games
Bookmakers adjust their lines when teams play multiple games in short windows. They account for fatigue, roster changes and bullpen availability.
The opening odds for the third game (September 23rd) reflected the expected lineup and pitching changes from the doubleheader. Sharp bookmakers like Pinnacle adjust quickly based on confirmed starting pitchers and lineup cards.
Total runs lines (over/under bets on combined score) also shift. Tired bullpens may give up more runs, but tired hitters may score fewer. The net effect depends on which team has better depth.
What Should You Watch?
Starting pitcher announcements matter more than usual. Teams sometimes adjust their rotation when a doubleheader forces them to use an extra starter. A team might start a less experienced pitcher in one doubleheader game to save their best arms.
Lineup cards (the official list of starting players) provide crucial information. If a team rests three or four regular starters in a game, the odds should reflect weaker offensive production. Check lineup cards about 90 minutes before first pitch.
Bullpen usage in earlier games directly impacts later games. If a team uses five relievers in the first game of a doubleheader, they have fewer fresh arms for games two and three. Some bookmakers are slow to adjust for this.
Start Tracking Compressed Schedule Value
Three games in 24 hours create opportunities that don’t exist in normal series. Soft bookmakers struggle to price these games accurately because their models don’t fully account for roster depletion and fatigue.
BetUnfair gives you the tools to spot these situations and compare odds across sharp and soft books in real time.
Sign up for a 5-day free trial and track the next compressed schedule series with Graph Center and EV Comparison.
FAQ
Why don’t teams always play doubleheaders to finish the season faster?
Players’ unions and teams agree on maximum games per time period to protect player health. Doubleheaders only happen when makeup games are necessary.
Do doubleheader games count the same in betting records?
Yes, each game in a doubleheader is a separate game for betting purposes with its own odds and outcomes.
How do bookmakers set totals for the third game after a doubleheader?
They estimate bullpen availability based on game one and two usage, adjust for expected lineup changes, and factor in historical scoring patterns from similar situations.
Can weather cause multiple games in one day?
Yes, a rainout earlier in the season creates the makeup game that becomes part of a doubleheader.
Do favorites perform worse in compressed schedules?
Not always. Teams with deeper rosters often handle compressed schedules better, which can include favorites. The key is roster depth and bullpen quality.
Should I bet all three games or wait for the final one?
Most value appears in the final game because information from games one and two creates clearer pictures of fatigue and roster depletion. However, value can appear in any game if soft books misprice the situation.
How quickly do soft books adjust after sharp books move?
Usually 5 to 30 minutes for major markets, sometimes longer for player props or smaller markets.
What sports besides baseball have compressed schedules?
Basketball and hockey sometimes play back-to-back games. Tennis tournaments have players competing on consecutive days. American football rarely has compressed schedules due to injury risk.
Keywords: doubleheader betting · compressed schedule odds · MLB makeup games · bullpen usage betting · fatigue factor sports betting · sharp vs soft bookmaker · dropping odds baseball · player props fatigue · value betting schedules · BetUnfair baseball tools